A Defensive Stance

The Carolina Panthers showed significant improvement on defense this year, and much of that progress can be credited to the return of Derrick Brown. Last offseason, the front office clearly prioritized the defensive line, spending heavily on the position group, much like they had done the year before with offensive guard.

I liked the approach, especially with Brown returning and A’Shawn Robinson in the mix. Robinson is a classic “glue guy,” but he is more than that. He brings size, toughness, consistency, and helps hold the front together. The signing of Bobby Brown was also solid, and I never understood why it took so long into the season for him to start getting more snaps. When he was on the field, his impact was noticeable. However, that move was somewhat offset, in my opinion, by the signing of Turk Wharton.

Not only did Wharton miss significant time with injury, but his production did not justify the investment. He felt like a luxury signing for a team closer to championship contention than this organization currently is. More importantly, his fit in this scheme is questionable. Outside of pass rushing, what does he really provide?

This defense runs a 3–4, which is designed to have three massive defensive tackles eat up blocks and free up linebackers and edge rushers. Wharton profiles more as an under tackle in a 4–3 or as a situational interior pass rusher in certain three man fronts. He does not naturally fit the core identity of this system.

Looking ahead, releasing A’Shawn Robinson could save cap space, but it would also create a major hole, especially when the defense is finally starting to look competent. That is a risky move for a unit that is still developing consistency.

The formula should be simple. On early downs and short yardage situations, roll with Derrick Brown, Bobby Brown, and A’Shawn Robinson. On passing downs, swap out Bobby Brown for Wharton. Keep it straightforward.

Heading into 2026, there is no need to overcomplicate the personnel. This defense works best when it leans into size, strength, and discipline up front. If the Panthers stick with that identity, the defensive line can continue to be a foundation for improvement.